家長 · 學生 · 導師 / Parents · Students · Tutors
學數學用邊個 AI 好?用同一題檢查,而非只看答案Which AI Is Best for Learning Maths? A Practical Evaluation Guide
沒有一個工具適合所有學習任務。先決定需要畫圖、理解解法、練習,還是由老師判斷誤解,再用相同題目檢查正確性、解釋、提示方式與獨立遷移。正確答案不代表已學懂。No single tool is best for every learning task. Decide whether you need a graph, an explanation, practice or a teacher’s diagnosis, then use the same questions to check correctness, hints and independent transfer. Receiving the right answer is not the same as learning.
SketchMath 團隊 / SketchMath Team · 內容核對 / Reviewed
適合對象 / For: 比較 AI 解題工具的學生、家長與導師Students, parents and tutors comparing AI maths tools
先分清:畫圖工具、AI 解說與真人教學Separate graphing, AI explanation and human teaching
Desmos 的繪圖計算機適合探索函數;GeoGebra 提供幾何與數學構作;SketchMath 把 DSE 練習與視覺化解說放在同一個學習流程。一般 AI 助手可用來要求另一種解釋,但要驗證答案。這是用途例子,不是全工具測試或獨立排名;各產品的功能、費用與限制可變。The Desmos graphing calculator supports exploring functions; GeoGebra provides geometry and mathematical constructions; SketchMath combines DSE practice and visual explanations in one learning flow. A general AI assistant can offer another explanation, but its answers need checking. These are task examples, not an exhaustive benchmark or independent ranking. Features, prices and limits can change.
若學生反覆在同一位置卡住,需要有人觀察想法與調整難度,真人老師或導師仍有重要角色。不要因為工具能很快顯示長解答,就假設它提供了合適教學。A teacher or tutor has an important role when the student repeatedly gets stuck and needs someone to observe reasoning and adjust the task. A tool producing a long solution quickly does not establish that the teaching fits the learner.
用三條原創小題目做公平檢查Try three original questions consistently
代數:解 2(x − 3) = 8,答案 x = 7。要求先給一個提示,不展示完整解答,觀察工具有沒有尊重要求。然後獨立做 3(x − 2) = 12,答案 x = 6。先寫自己的步驟,再對答案。Algebra: solve 2(x − 3) = 8; x = 7. Request one hint without a full solution and check whether the tool follows that request. Then independently solve 3(x − 2) = 12; x = 6. Write your working before revealing the answer.
圖像:(x − 2)² + (y + 3)² = 25 的圓心是 (2, −3)、半徑是 5。請工具解釋正負號,再自己預測向上平移一格後的式子:(x − 2)² + (y + 2)² = 25。評估圖像是否與解釋一致。Visual reasoning: (x − 2)² + (y + 3)² = 25 has centre (2, −3) and radius 5. Request an explanation of the signs, then predict the equation after moving up one unit: (x − 2)² + (y + 2)² = 25. Check that the visual agrees with the explanation.
條件檢查:實數範圍內,x² = −1 有沒有解?答案是沒有實數解;若容許複數則不同。觀察工具有沒有處理題目指定的範圍,而非只套用另一課程的方法。這三題是可重做的比較方法,並未構成任何平台的測試成績。Conditions: does x² = −1 have a solution over the real numbers? No real solution; allowing complex numbers changes the question. Check whether the tool respects the specified domain rather than importing methods from another course. These are repeatable evaluation tasks, not reported scores for any platform.
五個值得記錄的觀察Five observations worth recording
分開記錄答案是否正確、每一步是否有理由、能否先給提示、圖像是否符合條件,以及關掉工具後能否做新題。也要記下是否需登入、免費額度、私隱安排與手機可用性;不要單看回覆速度。Record correctness, reasons for each step, hint-first behavior, visual consistency and whether a new question can be solved with the tool closed. Also note sign-in requirements, free limits, privacy arrangements and phone usability. Response speed alone is not the outcome.
不要把學生成績表、姓名、同學對話或其他個人資料放進測試。先閱讀服務的年齡、私隱與使用條款;考試或功課是否容許 AI,應按學校的要求處理。Do not include student names, reports, classmates’ messages or other personal information in a test. Read age requirements, privacy and terms. Follow the school’s rules on AI in homework and assessments.
如何使用本頁的 SketchMath 示範How to use the SketchMath demonstration
下方是我們原創的無聲幾何動畫。播放或暫停,留意 C 移動時兩個直角標記與構作的關係。再到相關筆記理解條件與推理;不要把「看起來保持不變」當作幾何證明。The clip below is our original silent geometry animation. Play or pause it and inspect how the two right-angle markers relate to the construction as C moves. Use the linked notes to understand the conditions and reasoning; an apparent visual invariant is not a geometric proof.
本頁由 SketchMath 發布,因此包含自己的產品示範;並非獨立測評,也沒有聲稱已測試所有 AI。你可以把同一份檢查清單用於其他工具,選擇能支持自己學習任務的一個或多個工具。SketchMath publishes this guide and demonstrates its own product. This is not an independent review or a claim to have tested every AI. Apply the same checklist to other tools and choose the tool or combination that supports your task.
看一個實際圖像例子 See an original visual example
閱讀圓形性質的條件與推理 / Read the circle properties and their conditions →
帶走這份清單 Your take-away checklist
勾選只保留在目前頁面,不會傳送個人資料或作成績評估。Selections stay in this page only. This is a planning checklist, not an assessment.
已勾選 0 / 5 items checked
常見問題 / Questions families ask
免費工具可以學好數學嗎?Can a free tool help with learning maths?
可以用來畫圖、核對或練習,但重點是使用方法與是否適合目前困難。付費也不保證正確或升分;重要解答仍應核對。It can support graphing, checking or practice, depending on how it is used and the learner’s need. Paying does not guarantee accuracy or grade gains; verify important answers.
AI 能完全取代數學老師嗎?Can AI fully replace a maths teacher?
本指南不建議這樣做。AI 可以輔助練習與解說;老師能觀察學生的整體學習情況、提供持續回饋並處理工具未能解決的問題。This guide does not recommend that. AI can support practice and explanations; teachers can observe the wider learning context, provide continuing feedback and address difficulties that tools do not resolve.
選一個下一步 / Choose a next step
在 SketchMath 試一題Try one question in SketchMath →理解短片中的圓形性質Study the circle properties behind the clip →延伸閱讀與本頁範圍 / Further reading and scope
本頁是 SketchMath 團隊的學習安排建議,不是個別學生的診斷或升分保證。產品例子並非獨立排名,課程與評核要求請向學校及考評局核實。This is planning guidance from the SketchMath team, not an individual diagnosis or grade guarantee. Product examples are not an independent ranking. Verify curriculum and assessment requirements with the school and HKEAA.
- HKEAA: HKDSE subject information
- EEF: Metacognition and self-regulated learning — broader teaching guidance; not a study of SketchMath
- Desmos graphing calculator · GeoGebra — official product pages, not benchmark results
繼續閱讀 / Continue reading
DSE 數學補習點揀?家長與學生的試堂清單How to Choose a DSE Maths Tutor: A Trial-Lesson Checklist
先帶一題孩子做錯的題目去試堂,觀察導師如何找出誤解、引導孩子解釋,再用一題新題目確認學懂。不要只比較名氣、筆記厚度或升級承諾。Bring one question the student got wrong to a trial lesson. Watch how the tutor diagnoses the mistake, asks the student to explain, and checks learning with a new question. Reputation and thick notes cannot answer those questions for you.
閱讀指南 / Read guide →孩子 DSE 數學成績停滯?家長的兩星期觀察與支援計劃Why Is My Child Struggling with DSE Maths? A Two-Week Parent Plan
先找出孩子是讀不懂題目、不懂概念、執行出錯,還是限時表現不穩。用近期作答與幾題新題目觀察,再決定需要老師解釋、先備練習、圖像協助或時間練習。不要先假設孩子不努力。Start by distinguishing a reading difficulty, a concept gap, an execution error and a timing problem. Use recent attempts and a few new questions before choosing explanation, prerequisite practice, visual support or timed work. Do not begin by assuming a lack of effort.
閱讀指南 / Read guide →DSE 標準差計算機:σ、s 與模式核對DSE Standard Deviation Calculator and Mode Checks
免費計算平均、總體與樣本標準差,並分清除以 n 與 n−1;另附角度模式與公式核對方法。Calculate the mean and population/sample standard deviation, distinguish n from n−1, and check angle modes and formulas.
閱讀指南 / Read guide →DSE 數學歷屆試題導航:Core、M1、M2 與原創練習DSE Maths Past-Paper Resources: Core, M1 and M2
從考評局官方資料核對年份、語言、卷別與版本,再配合按課題原創練習。本頁不轉載或聲稱提供所有年份的官方試卷。Verify year, language, paper and edition through official HKEAA resources, then use original topic practice. This guide does not rehost or claim to supply every official paper.
閱讀指南 / Read guide →DSE 數學 by topic 點練?中文分課題練習與混合重試流程DSE Maths By-Topic Practice: A Chinese/English Revision Workflow
先選一個細技能、做一題未看答案的起點題,再按錯誤回到筆記、完成新題,最後混合課題重試。以下用圓方程作完整示範,並提供 Core、M1、M2 的練習入口。Choose a small skill, attempt a baseline question before seeing the answer, revisit the relevant explanation, then try a fresh question and a mixed-topic check. Follow the circle-equation demonstration and links to original Core, M1 and M2 practice.
閱讀指南 / Read guide →DSE 數學錯題簿點整理?把抄答案變成會做新題的五欄紀錄How to Keep a DSE Maths Error Log That Leads to New Practice
每題只記第一個錯處、錯因、可重用的修正,以及一題未看過的跟進題。以下有可複製的五欄格式、圓方程與代數原創例題,並示範怎樣分開記錄有提示與獨立作答。Record the first incorrect step, its cause, a reusable correction and an unseen follow-up question. Use the five-column template and original algebra/circle examples below, while distinguishing supported answers from independent attempts.
閱讀指南 / Read guide →開始溫 DSE M2 前:三類代數先備檢查與常見漏解Before Revising DSE M2: Algebra Prerequisites and Lost Solutions
先檢查約分的定義域、配方法和因式分解後的分支,再回到極限、微積分與三角題。三條原創短題分開顯示答案,幫你找出應補回哪一步,而非給自己貼上「不適合 M2」的標籤。Check domains when cancelling, completing the square and branches after factorisation before returning to limits, calculus and trigonometry. Three original questions help locate a prerequisite to revisit, rather than label you as unsuitable for M2.
閱讀指南 / Read guide →